The Impossible Birthday Gift

Lucy: Ben's birthday is tomorrow, and we still haven't bought him anything!

Mark: What about a book? He said he wanted to read more.

Lucy: I gave him a book last year. He said the ending was predictable.

Mark: A nice shirt, then?

Lucy: He hates shopping for clothes, and he never wears the shirt I bought him.

Mark: What does he actually like?

Lucy: Cooking, but he complains about expensive kitchen tools. He loves music, but he says most new bands sound the same.

Mark: This is impossible. Maybe we should buy him a cake.

Lucy: He doesn't like sweet food.

Mark: Right. Let's get him a cooking lesson. He can learn something new, and we don't have to guess which object he'll hate.

Lucy: Good idea! If he complains, at least we won't have to take it back.

Fiction note: All people, places and events in this dialogue are fictional.