The Perfect Employee

Manager: I've just received a call from the company you applied to. They wanted to check your reference.

Alex: That's good, isn't it? You said you'd write me a strong one.

Manager: I did. I said you were reliable, creative, and good at solving problems. All true.

Alex: Great. What's the issue?

Manager: You sent them a copy of the letter I wrote, didn't you?

Alex: Yes. You told me I could use it for applications.

Manager: Then why does it say you "single-handedly transformed the entire department"?

Alex: That was your wording.

Manager: I was being enthusiastic. You did improve the filing system, but you didn't transform the entire department.

Alex: You also called me "an indispensable strategic visionary."

Manager: I may have got carried away.

Alex: And you wrote that my leadership "inspired colleagues across the organisation."

Manager: You did organise the Friday lunch once.

Alex: A lunch that three people attended.

Manager: Four, if you count the delivery driver who stayed to find his receipt.

Alex: Look, I appreciate the reference, but it makes me sound like I ran the company. The new employer might expect me to arrive and redesign everything in a week.

Manager: I thought a little exaggeration would help you stand out.

Alex: A reference is supposed to help them understand what I can actually do. If you describe me as a miracle worker, I'll spend the interview explaining why I can't perform miracles.

Manager: Fair point. Would you like me to send a revised version?

Alex: Please. Say I improved the filing system, helped new staff, and kept the team organised. That's enough.

Manager: All right. I'll make it accurate, positive, and slightly less heroic.

Alex: Perfect. You can save "strategic visionary" for someone who has actually seen a strategy.

Fiction note: All people, places and events in this dialogue are fictional.