The Review Before the Review

Critic: You know the review goes live tomorrow, don't you?

Novelist: I do. I have spent the day pretending I don't.

Critic: That seems a sensible use of your first twenty-four hours as a published author.

Novelist: Is it a good review?

Critic: It is an honest one. I admire the ambition of the book. The structure is daring, and the central character refuses to behave in the way the plot requires. That is either a flaw or a sign of life.

Novelist: I was hoping you'd call it a sign of life.

Critic: I might have, if the final third hadn't explained every ambiguity the first two thirds had so carefully created.

Novelist: My editor said readers would feel cheated if I left the ending open.

Critic: Readers are not a single anxious committee. Some dislike uncertainty; others find it the most interesting thing a novel can offer.

Novelist: It's easy to say that when you're not the one being told your book is confusing.

Critic: Fair enough. But a review isn't a referendum on your right to write. It is an account of what happened when I read the book, and an argument for why I responded as I did.

Novelist: So you can dislike the ending without thinking the whole thing is a failure?

Critic: Of course. The problem is that the ending doesn't merely resolve the plot. It explains the meaning of the plot, then explains the explanation, as if you don't trust the reader to have noticed anything.

Novelist: I thought I was being generous.

Critic: You may have been. Generosity and trust are not always the same thing.

Novelist: That's going in my notebook, unfortunately.

Critic: Good. But don't turn it into a rule for the next book. You might write something that genuinely needs a clear ending. The question is whether the clarity has been earned.

Novelist: I wanted people to understand what I meant.

Critic: And I wanted to understand what you made. Those are not quite the same request.

Novelist: You make criticism sound less like a verdict than a conversation.

Critic: The best kind is. But tomorrow, when people read the review, they may not notice the conversation. They'll notice the score.

Novelist: Four stars?

Critic: Three.

Novelist: I'll pretend I didn't hear that.

Critic: Sensible. A promising career begins with selective hearing.

Fiction note: All people, places and events in this dialogue are fictional.