The Wine List of Opinions

Elena: You described our house red as "an ambitious wine wearing borrowed shoes." I assume that was meant to be an insult.

Martin: Not entirely. It had a pleasant finish, but the opening was all theatre. I expected complexity and got a grape clearing its throat.

Elena: Yet you praised the bottle we served with the main course, which costs six times as much. Was that wine genuinely better, or did the price help you discover its virtues?

Martin: The second wine had greater depth, a longer finish, and a more coherent structure. I can describe those qualities without consulting the bill.

Elena: Certainly. But you mentioned its price twice in your review. You never mentioned the producer's decision to use a lighter oak treatment, which is what made the wine work with the food.

Martin: A critic has limited space. Readers understand price more quickly than oak treatment.

Elena: Then perhaps your readers understand the price rather than the wine. A high price can reflect rarity, reputation, or a fashionable label. None of those guarantees pleasure in the glass.

Martin: And your profession has no incentive to encourage expensive choices, of course. The restaurant's margin on that bottle is hardly a philosophical question.

Elena: I won't pretend restaurants are charities. But I also won't pretend a guest enjoys a wine more simply because it costs more. Last month, a customer chose our cheapest white wine and paired it perfectly with a delicate fish dish.

Martin: Was that customer a better judge than I am?

Elena: They were paying attention to what they liked, rather than what they thought they ought to like. That's not the same thing as expertise, but it isn't nothing.

Martin: So you believe taste is entirely subjective?

Elena: No. Acidity, balance, and flaws can be discussed with some precision. Pleasure, however, is not a laboratory result. Expertise should explain an experience, not dictate it.

Martin: I may have mistaken confidence for discernment.

Elena: And I may have mistaken your expensive adjectives for expensive habits. We both have a professional image to maintain.

Martin: In that case, pour me the house red. I'll review it without looking at the price.

Elena: Gladly. But if you call it a grape clearing its throat again, at least give it a handkerchief.

Fiction note: All people, places and events in this dialogue are fictional.