The Committee That Approved Itself Twice

When the Department of Civic Improvements announced that every major project would require independent review, the director described the change as a victory for transparency. No proposal, she promised, would be approved without a fresh pair of eyes.

The first review committee was formed from experienced officials who had not worked directly on the projects under consideration. Its members examined budgets, checked timelines, and submitted a report recommending several sensible changes. So far, the new system appeared to be working.

Then someone noticed a procedural gap. The rules required an independent committee to review each committee report, but they did not specify how the independence of that second committee should be established. Rather than clarify the wording, the department created another panel and instructed it to assess the first panel's review process.

The second panel completed its work quickly. Its report stated that the first panel had followed the required steps. However, the report itself had not been independently reviewed. A third panel was therefore assembled to evaluate the second panel's report, including its conclusion about the first panel.

At this point, a junior clerk asked whether the department was checking the quality of its decisions or merely checking whether the checking had been performed. The question was recorded as a request for clarification and forwarded to the committee responsible for procedural questions.

That committee concluded that the existing rules had been followed. Since no rule explicitly prohibited a committee from reviewing its own review procedure, the process was technically acceptable. The department's annual report later announced that the oversight system had passed two independent assessments.

The director presented the result as evidence of exceptional accountability. The clerk, meanwhile, noticed that the original project proposals had not changed since the first review. The paperwork had multiplied; the recommendations had not.

No one had deliberately set out to avoid scrutiny. Each group had followed the instructions it received. Yet the system had gradually rewarded compliance with the procedure rather than attention to its purpose. The department had managed to approve its own independence twice, without ever answering the simplest question: had anyone actually checked whether the projects were any good?

Fiction note: All people, places and events in this text are fictional.