Clever on Your Wrist, Annoying in Your Pocket

I've worn the PulseTrack smartwatch for six weeks, and I have mixed feelings about it. It does several things well, but it can make small problems feel surprisingly personal.

The activity tracking is excellent. It records walks accurately enough for my needs, and weekly summaries reveal patterns I would otherwise miss. I used to think I was active because I walked at weekends. The watch showed me that I spent most weekdays sitting at my desk. Since buying it, I've started taking a short walk after lunch.

Battery life is another strong point. I usually get four days from a full charge, even with notifications enabled. That's a relief compared with my old device, which needed charging whenever I wanted to leave the house.

However, the watch isn't as smart as its name suggests. Its sleep tracker sometimes reports that I'm awake when I'm reading quietly in bed. It also reminds me to stand while I'm already standing in the kitchen. Once, it congratulated me for reaching my step target while I walked downstairs to answer the door. The praise felt premature.

Phone notifications are useful in theory, especially when I'm travelling or carrying shopping. In practice, the screen is too small for longer messages, and preset replies can cause confusion. I once sent "Sounds good!" in response to a message about a cancelled meeting. My colleague wasn't impressed.

The design is comfortable, and the strap hasn't irritated my skin. Still, the display can be hard to read in bright sunlight.

Would I recommend it? Yes, if you want a convenient activity tracker and don't expect it to replace your phone. No, if you need reliable sleep measurements or plan to answer messages regularly. It's a useful assistant, but not a particularly thoughtful one.

Fiction note: All people, places and events in this text are fictional.