When Daniel asked to borrow my car for one afternoon, I said yes without much thought. His own car was at the garage, and he needed to collect a desk he'd bought online. We'd been friends for years. I didn't expect a favour to become a test of that friendship.
He returned my car just after seven. The first thing I noticed was a dent in the rear passenger door. It wasn't enormous, but it certainly hadn't been there when he left.
“What happened?” I asked.
Daniel looked at the dent and frowned. “I found it like that when I came out of the shop.”
“You mean someone hit it while you were inside?”
“Probably. The car park was packed.”
I wanted to believe him. Daniel had never given me a reason to doubt him, but his explanation seemed incomplete. “Did you tell anyone at the shop?”
“No. I was already late, and I didn't know who had done it.”
That evening, I checked the photos I'd taken of the car the previous week. The door was clearly undamaged. I also noticed that Daniel hadn't mentioned the incident until I asked about the dent.
The next morning, he called me. He sounded different, less certain.
“I should tell you something,” he said. “I scraped the door against a concrete post while reversing. I panicked. I thought you'd be furious, so I said someone else had done it.”
I was angry about the damage, but even more disappointed that he'd lied. We discussed the repair cost. Daniel offered to pay for it in instalments, which I accepted. I also told him I needed time before lending him anything again.
He didn't argue. “That's fair,” he said.
The dent was eventually repaired. The conversation took longer to fix. We stayed friends, but the next time Daniel needed a favour, we both remembered that afternoon.
Fiction note: All people, places and events in this text are fictional.