The Committee on Naming Committees

The Department of Administrative Coordination had a naming problem. Its committees had names that were inconsistent, occasionally misleading, and sometimes longer than the reports they produced.

The Committee for Improving Internal Processes was also known informally as the Process Group, the Internal Improvement Panel, and, in one archived email, "the people who meet on Thursdays." Nobody could establish which title was official.

After a minor dispute over who had authority to approve a committee's name, the department created a new body: the Committee on Naming Committees. Its mandate was to produce a standard naming framework for all current and future committees.

At the first meeting, the chair, Ms Voss, proposed three principles: names should be accurate, concise, and easy to distinguish.

"Excellent," said Mr Pell. "Then we need a committee to define what counts as concise."

"We could define it ourselves," Ms Voss replied.

"That would exceed our remit," he said. "Our remit is naming committees, not defining the terms in our remit."

They agreed to establish a Working Group on the Definition of Concision. The working group requested guidance on whether "working group" was itself an acceptable committee designation. That question was referred back to the Committee on Naming Committees.

By the third meeting, the members had produced a preliminary list of approved terms: committee, panel, board, task force, and working group. They could not approve the list because they had not decided whether it should be called a list, a register, or a catalogue. Each term, they argued, implied a different level of authority.

Ms Voss suggested a temporary title: "Draft List of Possible Names for Departmental Committees."

Mr Pell objected that "possible" implied the existence of alternatives not yet formally documented.

A junior administrator named Imani, who had been taking minutes for six weeks, raised her hand.

"Could we call it the list?"

Everyone looked at her.

"Without deciding what kind of list?" asked Ms Voss.

"Yes."

The room fell silent. Then Mr Pell asked whether the suggestion had been formally submitted.

Imani looked at her notebook. "I can put it in the minutes."

The committee voted unanimously to defer the suggestion until the next meeting, when it could be reviewed under the appropriate agenda item.

Six months later, the department announced a new policy. Every committee would retain its existing name until the Committee on Naming Committees completed its framework. The committee's own name, however, had already been approved.

It was called the Committee on Naming Committees.

At least one thing, the department reported, had been named correctly.

Fiction note: All people, places and events in this text are fictional.