The landlord asked me for a short explanation of the proposed rent increase. He wanted a letter that sounded firm, reasonable, and, if possible, impossible to argue with. As his accountant, I could provide the first two qualities. The third was outside my professional remit.
I began with the figures. Insurance premiums had risen, the building's lift needed a major repair, and the heating system consumed more energy than it had five years earlier. The landlord's spreadsheet recorded each expense with admirable precision. It recorded the rent received, too, but not the hours spent chasing contractors or tenants' unresolved complaints.
“People will say the increase is unfair,” he told me.
“Some will,” I replied. “Others may accept the explanation. The figures cannot decide what people ought to feel.”
He disliked this distinction. He preferred arithmetic because it appeared to settle disputes without argument. If maintenance costs rose by a certain percentage, he reasoned, rent should rise by a corresponding amount. Yet the calculation concealed choices: which repairs were urgent, which improvements could wait, and how much of the additional cost should fall on tenants rather than the owner.
I asked whether he had considered spreading the lift repair over a longer period. He said the contractor's quotation was valid for only thirty days. I asked whether he had compared other contractors. He admitted that he had not, partly because the first company had been recommended by a neighbouring property manager. The recommendation might have been sound, but it was not a comparison.
Then we reached the proposed increase. His initial figure would cover the new expenses and preserve the profit margin he had expected when purchasing the building. I pointed out that the margin was an expectation, not a guaranteed entitlement. He reminded me that he had invested his savings and was responsible for the property's upkeep. Both statements were true, and neither made the decision automatic.
We revised the proposal. He agreed to obtain another repair estimate, explain maintenance costs in plain language, and separate necessary work from optional upgrades. The increase would be reconsidered once those figures were available. It was not the definitive letter he had requested, but it was a more defensible process.
When I finished, he asked whether I thought tenants would be satisfied.
“I can't calculate satisfaction,” I said. “But I can help you show your working.”
He laughed at that, perhaps because accountants are expected to believe every problem has a cell in a spreadsheet. In reality, numbers can clarify a decision without absolving the person who makes it. A rent increase may have a financial rationale and still impose a serious burden. Explaining the first does not erase the second.
Fiction note: All people, places and events in this text are fictional.